Showing posts with label hope and change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hope and change. Show all posts

Thursday, December 23, 2010

Malaysian Chronicle: 100-day reforms: BN has lost and Pakatan deserves a chance... by Mariam Mokhtar

100-day reforms: BN has lost and Pakatan deserves a chance

by Mariam Mokhtar
Malaysia Chronicle
Thursday, 23 December 2010

Deputy Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin scoffed at Pakatan’s 100-day reforms in the event that they formed the federal government and reminded the public ‘why BN has been in power for more than half a century and counting’.

His shameless attempt to discredit Pakatan is an insult to the electorate. He said, “Pakatan can promise the sun, moon, stars and mountains… But that is not the way of the BN government. We cannot squander our nation’s wealth.”

Muhyiddin is far removed from reality. People are disillusioned. After 53 years, the nation is more divided than ever, and our economy is in tatters. Our standards in education are falling, our defence budget is spiraling out of control and the civil service is bloated. The Prime minister’s residence and the King’s palace are undergoing a multi-million magical transformation whilst some people live without piped water and electricity.

Does Muhyiddin still think the electorate deserves to give BN another chance? Is 53 years of failure not long enough?

Muhyiddin said, “For BN, the prime minister has already a long road map for a high-income nation. But Pakatan only has plans for their first 100 days. They have absolutely no plans to reform the economy or anything.”

Only a megalomaniac will equate ‘high-spending’ with ‘high-income’? The mega-projects that the Prime minister announced are mere monuments to vanity, to satisfy BN’s perverse ego that bigger is always better.

The Pakatan led states of Penang and Selangor are examples of good governance and they have introduced younger voices to have a greater say in shaping policy On the other hand, BN’s talk sounds outdated and wearisome.

Malaysia’s lack of political reforms means that our ranking in ‘The Democracy Index’ is 71 out of 167 countries. Ours is defined as a ‘flawed democracy’. The Economist Intelligence Unit which compiles this index bases its findings on electoral process and pluralism, civil liberties, functioning of government, political participation and political culture.

Muhyiddin should realise that amongst other things, there is a restriction on our freedom of expression, the Internal Security Act is used to stifle criticism and university students are barred from participation in politics.

Would the DPM care to come up with a similar package for reform because the only things most people remember from the BN convention are Najib’s four political diseases ‘inertia, delusion, amnesia and arrogance’. Besides, its 7-point charter lacked not just lustre but also substance.

Unsurprisingly, Muhyiddin belittles not just the opposition, but also the public and companies. He said, “They probably think that the general election is close, so maybe they know better than us. They are just luring voters with their empty promises, like a supermarket sale.”

Not content with insulting the electorate, our DPM must also ridicule the retailers. He believes that ‘supermarket sales’ are just a gimmick with ‘their empty promises’.

One sincerely hopes the consortium of Malaysian retailers such as Giant, Tesco and Carrefour will protest at such a damaging charge.

If Pakatan has to make good on its promises, as pledged in its 100-day reform, then it also faces a long, thankless slog repairing the damage and economic mess of 53 years of BN rule.

Pakatan has dared to announce their reforms and it is for the electorate to choose if they are attractive enough for deciding their future.

Has BN been as ambitious in its political reforms? As far as many can see, BN’s policies are more of the ‘same-old, same-old’.

At least Pakatan leaders are on the right track. It has shown preparedness, clarity and bold vision for a better government. Who dares wins!

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

malaysiakini: Politicians, put collective good above self... by Capt Abdul Aziz Abdullah

Politicians, put collective good above self
Capt Abdul Aziz Abdullah
Dec 20, 2010
2:18pm

I refer to the article 'This time, Guan Eng is the star of the show' on Dec 19, 2010.

Indeed, if many amongst the diehard members of Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) can readily accept the fact that the party is not the domain of a particular individual and that its existence is for the betterment of Malaysia's society at large, then, in my humble opinion, I think it will survive with greater success and stronger support.

It may have been initially conceived with the pristine aim of ensuring justice to a particular individual, then, enduring unjust acts by powers-that-be, but, now, as a national political party with aspirations to rule the nation, that raison d'etre must be discarded and all focus ought be towards amalgamating the diaspora of conflicting interests by individual parties within the Pakatan Rakyat coalition.

All effort must be made to focus on this fundamental objective, no more on trying to ascertain that a prima donna's aim of being numero uno in the political hierarchy be the penultimate target!

We should adhere to the notion that no individual is so indispensable that the party/coalition is unable to function should he not be present. If one truly loves the party and all that it stands for, then, in my mind, it would be a far, far noble task for one to ensure that the party succeeds without him around!

That would, indeed, be an act of a genuine statesman, a patriot!

As such, may I remind all who care to listen that the rakyat is tired!

Exhausted by the relentless jibes of those currently in power exhorting that they, and only they, know best what is good for the country and assuming that Malaysians do not have the ability to think and discern for themselves of what is going on.

Exasperated at the antics of those who were given a sudden mandate to rule, not because they were good, but more so due to the indignation of blatant arrogance of the then incumbents, but, now appearing to be no better than those who were kicked out!

Is this the fate to befall us, fellow Malaysians? We speak of a two-party system, but the looks of it infer that neither is much different from the other!

We would wish to try out the alternative, but, need more convincing that it is a viable one, concerned and caring for the plight of ordinary folks and not beholden to the attraction of the mighty ringgit! We dream of ideals that can carry Malaysia into the developed world, but, not at the expense of maligning the environment. We abhor corruption, we adore frugality, we applaud transparency, but, above all, we cherish highly the unity that ordinary Malaysians practice, despite what many may try to destroy for their own selfish needs!

Thus, Pakatan, prove to us that you are that alternative that we can rely on. Shed the cloak of mistrust and back-stabbing that some are prone to practice within the coalition. You have some quite splendid personalities in your grouping with potential to shine and rise. Give them a chance, let those tried and tested, but, failed to deliver, rest and write their memoirs.

We appreciate their deeds, we'll remember their contributions, but, do not let them hold sway that sans their presence, the party will go to the dogs! That would be quite unfair to us, fellow Malaysians!

Monday, December 20, 2010

Malaysiakini: 1Choice for Malaysia... by Mariam Mokhtar

1Choice for Malaysia

Malaysiakini
Mariam Mokhtar
Dec 20, 2010

Malaysia’s upcoming general election offers the country its most significant choice for several decades.

The political tsunami of 2008 was an eye-opener. At the second Pakatan Rakyat convention in Kepala Batas, PAS president Abdul Hadi Awang acknowledged the weaknesses in the opposition pact and urged party member to unite and remain focused.

The nation faces enormous challenges in the years to come. The economic demands are tremendous.

The next government needs to stabilise the economy and stimulate growth in the private sector. It has to deal with its burgeoning debt, cut subsidies and rein in borrowings if it does not want to risk bankruptcy.

Our problems are not just economic. We are faced with a rising tide of extremism from Malay groups, borders which are porous, a rise in Islamic fundamentalism, a rise in racist incidents, problems in our schools and hospitals, the destruction of the police and judiciary, babies being abandoned, high levels of corruption and a weakening of civic society.

These problems demand a robust solution and a strong government to tackle them. The burning question is: Which party is best suited to lead us out of this quagmire?

PKR recently held elections, whilst BN and the other component parties have deferred theirs. DAP and Gerakan have followed suit. This is indicative of the pressures these political parties face. All want to mount a strong challenge when the country goes to the polls.

The parties have resolved to capture the imagination of the voters and the differences between them are obvious. BN believes that only it can solve the country’s economic and social ills. Its slogan 1Malaysia remains just that – a slogan because in practice, certain races are held back by an invisible wall – the ketuanan Melayu (Malay supremacy) concept.

In contrast, the Pakatan coalition believes that it can do a better job. It realises that the public mindset is changing. Race-based politics is a thing of the past. It is convinced that Malaysia is an increasing enlightened nation which believes in justice, the recognition of the rights of everyone regardless of race and that each Malaysian desires to be a part of the nation and be able to contribute towards its future.

The future of Malaysia, according to the BN administration, is to capitalise on mega-projects to boost the economy, just as during the Mahathir era.

In his Budget 2011 debate, Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahim said the BN’s obsession with “grandeur” will presage its fall.

He said: “This rush for symbolic mega-projects, supposedly to portray pride for the country, is being repeated now under the present prime minister. Here I would like to question the wisdom of Permodalan Nasional Bhd’s order from the government to involve itself in mega projects.”

One of these is the 100-storey Warisan Merdeka skyscraper which is expected to cost over RM5 billion. When completed, it will be the tallest building in Malaysia.

Risky strategy
PM Najib Abdul Razak’s plans for mega-projects to stimulate the economy is risky as it fails to consider the country’s current economic standing and the need to lower the budget deficit and improve competitiveness.

Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Idris Jala has said that Malaysia’s debt would rise to 100 percent of GDP by 2019 from the current 54% if the government does not cut subsidies.

He said: “We do not want to be another Greece. We do not want to end up like Greece with a total debt of EUR300 billion. Our deficit rose to record high of RM47 billion last year.”

Malaysia’s foreign direct investment (FDI), he said, dropped 81 per cent from RM23.47 billion in 2008 to RM4.43 billion in 2009, in comparison with Thailand which recorded an FDI of RM19.01 billion and Indonesia with RM19.08 billion.

Pakatan has warned of an economic crisis due to crony capitalism and corruption; a social crisis due to narrow racial policies; and a political crisis due to democratic fatigue arising from the BN’s abuses of power.

Corrupt practices only bring benefits to cronies and hefty losses to the people. Malaysia’s failure to attract foreign investment shows a desperate need for change in the management of the economy. Both good governance and a need to improve its competitive edge are vital.

Pakatan has decided to uphold a joint policy and welfare programme to defend the people based on four basic principles:

• A transparent and real democracy
• A high and stable economic performance
• Social justice and human development
• A close relationship between state-federal and international policies

Armed with these principles, Pakatan is determined to make Malaysia a better place. The three parties may have their roots in different ideologies – PAS (Islamic credentials), DAP (social ideology) and PKR (liberal ideals).

Perhaps you would prefer to have a government which relies on the Internal Security Act to stifle criticism, one in which corruption goes unchecked and where the judiciary and police are mere stooges of the state.

In order to make the necessary changes to this country, Anwar and his coalition must have a clear mandate to govern.

The best choice for Malaysia is in your hands. Vote wisely! May all your wishes come true – Happy Christmas!

MARIAM MOKHTAR is a non-conformist traditionalist from Perak, a bucket chemist and an armchair eco-warrior. In ‘real-speak’, this translates into that she comes from Ipoh, values change but respects culture, is a petroleum chemist and also an environmental pollution-control scientist.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Free Malaysian Today: Keeping March 8 alive.... by Stephanie Sta Maria

Keeping March 8 alive

by Stephanie Sta Maria
Free Malaysia Today
Tue, 14 Dec 2010

FMT EXCLUSIVE The day had not begun particularly well for Kee Thuan Chye. A friend – once a staunch supporter of political change – had confided that he was contemplating reverting to the “devil he knew” in the next general election.

“I was very upset,” Kee said. “After staying for so long on the track of change, he is giving up because he has lost faith in Pakatan Rakyat’s ability to get its act together to govern this country.”

It was the sort of sentiment that the former journalist found deeply troubling as it preyed on a simmering disquiet that the tide behind the March 8 tsunami may be turning again, this time in favour of the ruling party. And that, in Kee’s view, would spell imminent political tragedy for Malaysia.


March 8 is a historic date that Kee holds close to his heart. Two years ago he paid tribute to it with a book entitled “March 8: The Day Malaysia Woke Up”, an anthology of the voices that believed in and voted for change.

Now a second edition of that volume has hit the shelves. Only this time it bears the title “March 8: Time For Real Change”.

“The new title is apt for these times and besides, the publisher liked it!” he said, the corners of his eye crinkling. “But seriously, the next general election is approaching and there is an urgency now to talk about real change. There is also a need to assess all that has happened in the past two and half years.”

“The real purpose of a second edition is, of course, to keep the March 8 spirit alive. That is extremely important because Malaysia has not been the same since that day.”

Defining moment
There is a marked distinction between the spirit of March 8 and that of reformasi (the basis upon which PKR was formed). In drawing a line between the two, Kee declared that the former was much bigger in that it involved the country’s future while the latter was intertwined with the “Anwar personality”.

“March 8 was the defining moment when Malaysians realised that they had been taken for a ride for decades and that it was time for change,” he added. “It was a very important watershed which has to be commemorated.”

“Our spirit is different now and we must maintain it because with it comes the spirit of standing up for our rights. Of defying with a cause and of even showing healthy disrespect for authority when it is necessary. We have been docile and unquestioning for far too long. March 8 changed all that.”

Some 60% of the second edition is new material that was cobbled together within an impressive five months. But if the earlier sentiment of Kee’s friend is any indicator of a waning adrenaline, then it begs the question of whether this new volume is a boon or a bane. Kee already knows the answer.

“I think the enthusiasm is still there though it may be flagging a little now,” he said quietly. “I asked someone the other day whether a book like this would still sell and he said that people are a little tired of March 8 because of all the politicking that followed it.”

Nevertheless, he forged ahead in fierce determination to do his bit in keeping the enthusiasm pulsing.
To keep fanning that spirit that pushed people to raise and debate issues, exercise their rights and lobby for change.
 
“There are some very good and even brilliant ideas in this edition,” he promised. “And good advice for the next general election. There are good assessments of the chicanery that has been going on since March 8, and good summaries of how we have come to where we are now. The book will also remind people to think hard about their vote at the next general election.”

This hard thinking, unfortunately, may be sparked less by Barisan Nasional’s gaffes than by PKR’s recent antics. Even Kee voiced alarm over the less than savoury image that the BN is painting of the opposition coalition.

“Pakatan is losing ground and public confidence,” he noted. “Perception is so important in politics. DAP and PAS are very solid. PKR is the only weak link and it really has to buck up fast. There’s not much time left. It has to go to the ground to convince the people, especially the fence-sitters, that the opposition is still a viable option.”

Irrelevant concern
Many have questioned whether Pakatan is ready to take over the government but to Kee, this is an irrelevant concern. He believes that if one is thrown into the deep end of the pool, one will learn to swim. He also believes in giving the underdogs a chance.

“There is never a time when one is ready,” he asserted. “You have to approach the moment and when the moment arises you have to rise to the occasion. You have to give people a chance.”

“If it doesn’t work out there will be another election five years later. But it’s always worthwhile to take that chance because if you don’t, the change may never happen or it will happen too slowly.”

The most pressing need, according to Kee, is to remove a coalition that has been in power for 53 years so it knows what it is like to wear the other shoe. In the best-case scenario, that newly minted opposition will be forced to reform itself and the people would be presented with two stronger choices in the next general election. And in his opinion, two choices are enough.

“We don’t need a Third Force,” he said plainly. “It would be better for those who want to be part of this Third Force to offer themselves as candidates to Pakatan instead.”

“The Third Force here won’t be like the Tea Party in America. They had two years to build their profile and were very active and well organised. And even then quite a number didn’t get elected. Frankly I don’t know if the Third Force will do well because many of them will be unknown.”

Kee pointed out that many of the Third Force candidates would also be greenhorns in the political arena with only integrity for their sword and shield.

While he acknowledged that this would lessen the likelihood of defections, he warned that being person of integrity and a politician were two different matters altogether.

“It isn’t enough to just have integrity,” he reasoned. “You also have to be politically savvy. A person with integrity alone will get disillusioned very quickly. But if they want to continue with this Third Force, then they should make a pact with Pakatan. Even if it doesn’t win the next election at least we have a strong opposition.”

And if Pakatan stays on a losing streak? Kee, who has long refused to migrate, laughed.

“I’m still hoping that if there is a new government then perhaps the political reform can happen. But if there is still no change, I should really pack my bags and leave.”

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

ANU Lecture: Social Justice and Political Change: The Malaysian Experience.... By Anwar Ibrahim

Social Justice and Political Change: The Malaysian Experience

Lecture by Anwar Ibrahim at the Australian National University, Canberra, Monday, 15th November 2010

I would like to take a moment to express our joy on the release of Aung San Su Kyi. As we all know, her right to political office was denied through the most repressive of means. But driven by her conviction for freedom and democracy, Aung San Suu Kyi soldiered on from strength to strength against all odds. This long overdue freedom will nevertheless give renewed hope for the people of Burma and she will continue to inspire freedom fighters and champions of democracy and justice throughout the world.

Speaking of democracy and justice, I see a clear nexus with the topic at hand. Here in Canberra, no doubt a shining symbol of democracy in Asia, it is apt that I begin my talk on social justice with a clear statement of what democracy entails. Apart from the fundamental requirements of freedom and the rule of law, democracy is also presumed to be defined by the conditions of a free market. And this is where the founding fathers of the French Revolution with their clarion call for liberty, equality and fraternity missed their mark.

This is because a free market is based on competition, and competition, being a zero-sum game has no truck with equality. On the contrary, free market engenders inequality so much so that even the bastions of capitalism such as America and Britain no longer ask whether states ought to intervene in order to reduce these inequities.

The question is to what extent? The invisible hand has remained invisible so often that governments in the free world have not only intervened but have in some cases staked out their territory in areas which were once considered totally off-limits.

Various explanations have been given. The most defensible at least in theory is social justice. According to one view, state intervention is advocated by a “soft-hearted majority” while a “hard-boiled minority” would willingly accept or even rejoice in the inequality.1 This seems to suggest that at least for a certain segment of society, inequality is not seen to be unjust. Defenders of the French Revolution claim that equality has less to do with wealth than with equal treatment before the law. But we all know that deprived of the basic necessities of living, the law is a luxury that the poor man cannot afford. Hence, the need for social justice.

But this begs the question: is there an objective standard of social justice? Philosophers have locked horns on this and I don’t intend to reinvent the wheel here. Nevertheless, to put the issue in proper perspective, from John Locke we are told that “every man has by nature the right to possess property as his own.” We may therefore reasonably deduce that social justice is not in the equation here. John Rawls talks about ‘justice as fairness’ and advocates the notion of distributive justice. Libertarians such as Robert Nozick contend that justice can only be attained through a minimalist state. In other words, there is no room for distributive justice let alone social justice.

In Christianity, particularly under Catholic social teaching, life and dignity of the human person is predicated on the belief that the state must play a moral role to ensure social justice. This is not far from the essence of Mencius’s teachings in advocating that actions are to be judged by their moral correctness, not mere economic benefit. And Islam enjoins that while society may pursue commerce to its fullest, justice and fairness in dealings must remain the chief criterion. Social justice is enjoined in order to establish a humane economy. The point is that advocates of social justice today are in good company and need not feel that they have to be unshaven Bohemian leftists or disgruntled anti-globalization activists to show that they are genuine.

However, you can’t be calling for social justice without expecting political change. Inequalities of wealth, power and status are certainly not the privilege of nations practicing free markets though it is true that in theory socialist states have more egalitarian policies. That’s only the theory because reality bites hard and we know the enormous price that people under socialist regimes have had to pay for the so-called egalitarian lifestyle. To be equally poor is of no consolation. As Martin Luther Jr. once said: “The curse of poverty has no justification.”

Political change is therefore a condition precedent to attaining social justice if it is shown that a society is heading down the road to greater social perdition under its present government. There must be political will to change its socio-economic policies. In this regard, the Economic Transformation Program that was recently unveiled by the Najib administration bears analysis. The numbers are impressive, if not altogether mindboggling. All told, we are looking at more than RM1 trillion in so-called expansionary development and projects calculated at transforming a middle-income economy to a high-income economy.

On closer analysis, however, we are unable to connect the dots to see that critical mass in poverty reduction programs that would be needed to narrow the current gap between the rich and the poor. To seriously address the growing GINI coefficient, general and vague expressions of targeting for higher per capita income simply won’t do. We don’t see concrete plans to address the housing problems of the poor and a blue print for universal free education. We don’t see any comprehensive health care for those who can’t afford private medication and hospitals.

What we see is a frenzied conviction to outdo the megalomaniacal visions of the Mahathir era. We see grandiose designs, humongous structures, buildings taller than the KLCC Twin Towers and other mega projects that are destined to make crony companies outperform others in the share market and the rich and powerful, richer and more powerful. On balance, we see monumental wastage at the expense of the people and the environment. We see the future of our children and the generations to come being sacrificed on the altar of greed and the illegitimate amassing of wealth.

The rent-seeking culture will continue with the manner in which multi-million ringgit contracts are doled out. The issues of governance, transparency and accountability are not addressed even as the indices on transparency and corruption continue to drive investors away. Transforming an economy cannot be done through mere theory –the litmus test is implementation. The condition precedent to passing this test is to put an end to the culture of corruption, rent-seeking, and power abuse.

Now, at this juncture one may well accuse me of being a socialist advocating a welfare state. The answer to that is simple: I make no apology for calling for a more equitable distribution of wealth in as much as I make no apology for maintaining that the safeguarding of fundamental liberties is also one of the main ends of political and social justice. These liberties are of paramount importance but as Amartya Sen has argued, other considerations including that of economic needs are just as vital.
To my mind, he has posed a stunningly simple but compelling question: “Why should the status of intense economic needs, which can be matters of life and death, be lower than that of personal liberties?”2

In my humble view, some basic formulations for the attainment of social justice may be advanced. Governments must be committed to the principle that a more equitable distribution of income is a fundamental precept for the realization of social justice. It is on this platform that I urge my government to undertake integrated plans for poverty reduction in the long run while ensuring a comprehensive support system for the poor and economically marginalized. Economic power must be checked by the principles of governance and accountability. Are we supposed to sit idly by as politicians in public office continue to renege on their promises of social justice while scandalizing the institutions of power with abuse and corrupt practices?

Finally, the discourse on social justice and political change in the context of Malaysia must also be seen in the light of our multi-cultural make up where communal tensions run the risk of being exploited by “sectarian demagoguery”.3 We must therefore reject ideological rigidity and the politics of hate and exclusiveness in all its forms. Politics of this kind engenders divisive barriers whether they are founded on ethnicity, language or religion.

When communal violence erupts and innocent lives are lost, a nation is jolted into the realization that peace and harmony among the people is always a transient phenomenon. One day, it’s there and the next day, it may just come tumbling down under the weight of sectarian strife, or religious conflict or class wars arising from social inequities and economic deprivation.

It is often only after the fact, when events of a cataclysmic nature unfold, that the policy makers and social pundits get jolted to the reality that freedom could be meaningless without food on the table or that the rule of law may still discriminate on grounds of caste, wealth and status.

This is the caveat, the mental construct we should bear in mind when we talk about social justice and political change in Malaysia. It is a stark reminder that peace in our time must be more important than just material progress. In a multi-cultural society like Malaysia’s it is therefore incumbent on leaders to shoulder the responsibility as protectors of this fragility.

In this regard we must condemn in the strongest terms the racist chanting of modern day demagogues. Playing to the gallery is well and good if all we’re looking for is just a good round of applause. But when you have at your disposal the organs of state power and the entire state controlled electronic and print media, the propagation of supremacist doctrines backed by the threat of violence is not only immoral and utterly irresponsible but blatantly criminal.

At the very least, we would expect such leaders to urge for inclusiveness and greater understanding and respect among the communities and not to stoke the fire of racial discord.

To paraphrase Macbeth, they should against the murderer shut the door, not bear the knife themselves.
Thank you.

Monday, May 31, 2010

Malaysiakini: People must show their power

David KL Quek
Malaysiakini, May 24, 10
11:46am
 
Recent ugly polemics and rising ethno-religious tensions press for an urgent change for a better sociopolitical environment for Malaysians. The common rakyat must take up the cudgels to more properly engage with our evolving society as we totter along towards some form of democratic maturity.

We need to take charge to be involved in our increasingly complicated and contentious sociopolitical discourses. 


university malaya student demostration 050210 02More of us should be more forthcoming and join in this rising chorus of advocacy, of passionate vocalising and sharing, but especially for more of positive communitarian rather than negative partisan actions. More than 50 years of smouldering if passive acquiescence is enough.

We must now awaken and become individual and/or collective agents of change for a better Malaysia. Although my political inclinations are probably not secret, I wish to categorically state that I am not a member of any political party.

Let me quote from Vaclav Havel, playwright, writer, social critic, samizdat (underground writing) pioneer, and reluctant first president of the then newly emancipated Czech Republic, who went on to win the Nobel Peace prize.

In his first speech (New Year's day, 1990) Havel talked about the "contaminated moral environment", which the Czech Republic had just broken free from. Although taken from a different context and era, I believe it still applies equally well to our Malaysian situation. I quote:

"We live in a contaminated moral environment. We fell morally ill because we became used to saying something different from what we thought... Only a few of us were able to cry out loud that the powers that be should not be all-powerful... we cannot blame the previous rulers for everything... because it could blunt the duty that each of us faces today, namely, the obligation to act independently, freely, reasonably, and quickly... Freedom and democracy include participation and therefore responsibility from us all."


Thus, Malaysians must to ponder upon and seize this heightened awareness and crucial moment in history for greater engagement, and perhaps empowerment. I believe we all have a tremendous if obligatory stake in our own nation building. 

We are who we are, because of what and how we choose to do, or not to do. We should be the masters of our own fate and destiny. We must continue to believe that change for the better is possible.

Contrary to what many people may think, there appears to be a convergence of many minds in our Malaysian society. Lawyers, doctors, economists, academicians, professional bodies and NGOs are more and more aligned to a common objective, where we hope to have a greater say and influence in the direction of where our country is going.

Former Bar Council chairperson Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan had said that: "Malaysians have changed dramatically; we are more vocal, we are not prepared to suffer in silence or to watch others suffer and most importantly we see clearly what is happening before us. We are bored with explanations or statements that insult our intelligence... There must be a "passive resistance" by the people against unjust actions.
orang asli protest putrajayaWe have seen ordinary people producing extraordinary results when they stand firm against injustice, dishonesty and the destruction of our institutions. Indeed, what we have seen is an awakening of the will, wisdom and the collective conscience of the Malaysian people. And that is a formidable force that those in power ignore at their peril."

The involvement of doctors

Speaking from a point of view of a socially conscious physician, I believe that personally and as a professional group, doctors can help contribute to a more meaningful but less contentious politically charged environment.

As doctors, we are expected to take on leadership and stewardship roles in health and patient issues, to help enhance human dignity. We are exhorted to more directly impact on society so that our professionalism, our acclaimed ethical bearings can be put to better use. 

Some have even insisted that we take on the lead in directing rather than advising policy makers i.e. engage with politicians and even indulge in politics.

Although some of us more traditional physicians may baulk at this idea, it is good to note that even as early as in the mid-nineteenth century (1848), physician-pathologist Rudolf Virchow had said that "Politics is nothing more than medicine on a grand scale."

Rudolf Ludwig Carl Virchow was indeed a magnificent exemplar of a quintessential renaissance man. Not contented with just discovering leukaemia, distinguishing postmortem thrombosis from embolism, mastering microscopic examination of cells and tissues, and founding cellular pathology and pathologic physiology, Virchow was also known to be an incurable public service advocate.

Virchow felt his social duty keenly: "Medicine is a social science and as the science of man, has a duty to perform in recognising these problems as its own and in offering the means by which a solution may be reached... medicine has carried us into the social sphere, there to meet up with the great problems of our time." "Physicians," he articulated, "are the natural attorneys of the poor." 

Virchow of course went on to be elected into the Berlin City Council, the Prussian House of Deputies and later becoming a member of the Reichstag. He was a co-founder of the German Progressive Party.

Thus perhaps, it is not too much to expect that the modern day physician also share some of the traits of this outstanding man. Increasingly, I believe the medical profession is called upon to be more socially engaged.
Being among the more favoured and endowed cognoscenti, we should lead in matters not just pertaining to health and healthcare, but perhaps to even actively shape its ultimate form and function.

But should we just limit ourselves to only things medical or health? I believe otherwise. Indeed, I venture to say that the expected public roles and responsibilities of the physician have changed and have expanded.

Of course, quite a number of Malaysian doctors have already steeped themselves in politics, and then some. We are keenly aware of some of our more astute if rambunctious physicians, not a few of whom have led us down garden paths of crumbling political wilderness and had contributed to so much of our maligned if fractured institutions.

In many ways therefore, as physicians, our moral covenant with society needs to be renewed, indeed our moral imperative needs to be redefined, rekindled. In 1901, an editorial in the BMJ, extolled the possible potential power of the doctor in politics, if only we choose to use this effectively, and I quote:

"The medical profession is treated by politicians as a negligible quantity, but this is partly because it does not know, and partly because it does not care to use, its power. What doctors could do if they chose to use the legitimate influence which they have..."


Perhaps it is time to reconsider our role and ask ourselves just as Alice in Wonderland had been asked: '"Who are you?" said the caterpillar. "I hardly know, sir, just at present," Alice replied rather shyly, "at least I know who I was when I got up this morning, but I think I must have been changed several times since then."'

Sociopolitical cynicism runs high

The political climate in Malaysia is overcast, fickle and unpredictable-there have been floods, drought, earthquakes and even tsunamis!

There is pervasive cynicism and a brooding sense of despondency and uncertainty. Many are disenchanted, angry, yet deep-down faintly hopeful that some better sense will prevail to propel us forward into a new deal, a renewed sense of belonging.

We hanker for a more meaningful and inclusive unity and seamless sharing, rich with our cultural diversity, yet without all the ethnic baggage and baiting, racist taunting, scandalous corruption and insulting polemics.

The public is clamouring for a clearer moral direction and certainty for our nation. Just shouting the jingoistic "1Malaysia" is not enough; it must be heartfelt and not simply lip service. Perhaps our leaders must set the perfect examples if we hope to believe in their purported visions.

While perusing the Times magazine recently, I came upon the British election story, where I was somewhat surprised to note that even there, political skepticism runs high. 

David Cameron, Conservative leader and now just elected British PM had said during the election campaigning that, "People just aren't cynical about politicians. They're pretty bloody angry; I'm sickened by what's happened in our politics... Change vs. more of the same is the big clarion call. The change we need, the change we believe in, change we can trust, change that happens-call it what you want."

So social skepticism is not something peculiar or special to Malaysian politics. Malaysia is perhaps just a grosser example of escalating and exasperating excesses: of 'endemic' fraud, gratuitous graft, crippling corruption, wanton patronage, unchecked abuse of power; of terrible profligacy and wastage. But clearly we are not alone in this.

NONEWhen championing Benigno (Noynoy) Aquino III (right), in the recent Philippines presidential elections, Newsbreak magazine editor, Maritas Vitug echoed the cry of the populace: "Our trust in politics has been so eroded that the people just want a new leader who will do the very best-who will not be corrupt, who will be good."

Perhaps, such expectations and wishes are the common public cry for change for the better. Perhaps, they are simply too good to be true. Perhaps this wistful thinking will forever remain elusive, but this has not stopped many people the world over, from yearning for more moral leaders-maybe the 'least bad' will do.

Scurrilous shenanigans
Our own leaders seem mired in petty and scurrilous shenanigans, which appear to tear at the social fabric of our nation. Thus, more enlightened citizens are desperately looking up to someone or anyone, whom they can trust, to displace the overflowing cynicism that has pervaded our sociopolitical space.

The recent Hulu Selangor by-election results point to the state of confusion of what our diverse rakyat wants. The political fault-line is wafer thin (1725 votes). The Sibu by-election reinforced this view that the public is almost equally confused, with the opposition winning by just 398 votes in a bitterly fought campaign. Malaysians appear evenly divided at this juncture, although ethnic divides have widened, hardened even.

It appears that mundane local issues too easily sway us. National interests often take a backseat, trumped by parochial issues, which if 'promised' piecemeal ad hoc resolutions, or even overt pork-barrel goodies, we could be nudged to choose one way or the other. 

Perhaps money politics and promises (tens to hundreds of millions of ringgit exchanging hands?) and proffered political positions(senatorships) can buy just about anything in this Malaysian climate of blatant self-serving venality.

Sadly, even as we grapple with that narrow win or loss, depending on which side you stand, other dispiriting issues continue to dominate our sociopolitical landscape and shatter the myth of a harmonious well-ordered society.
It is sad when foreign political observers, deride our political maturity by decrying our intellectual naïveté, and slam our petty mindedness!

Australian AsiaRisk commentator, Manjit Bhatia in a hard-hitting commentary, believed that "Malaysian politics has become more and more of desperation than of cleverness or even of organic intelligence."
His comments that Malaysian politics are mired in primordial 'political psychology' rooted in racial baggage and 'morally bankrupt divide-and-rule' games, rather than via essence of true intellectual discourse, are worth contemplating.

military malaysia navy french built submarine scorpene classWe are riven with oppressive graft and highly questionable practices. We have that RM8 billion military contract to purchase some 257 APCs (each costing more than the best made US Abrams tank in the world!); the scandalous RM3.4 billion purchase of Scorpene submarines; we have that 76 million ringgit investment of lobbying time with President Obama and some American politicians/businessmen; we have that uncovered sale of oil-rich sea blocks off Limbang to Brunei; that brazen RM12 billion Port Klang Free Trade Zone debacle; and the fatal police shooting of a young 15-year old boy out for a midnight joy ride in his sister's car, etc.

Hence, it is not surprising that a late 2009 Merdeka Centre poll showed: corruption and abuse of power, social problems, crime and public safety, and political uncertainty as the top six most problematic concerns in the country!

It is therefore, not wrong to suggest that the informed Malaysian skeptic now believes that our civic institutions are systematically corrupt and crumbling-from the perceived one-sided trigger-happy prosecutorial law enforcement authorities, our ostensibly amoral politicians, to our seemingly browbeaten judicial system.

Our self-censoring mainstream media are a shameful testimony of a sycophantic pliant state of affairs! When two media producers (ntv7 producer Joshua Wong and RTM TV2 producer Chou Z Lam) resigned due to undue pressure and censorship problems, pathetic half-hearted cries for more press freedom finally made some headlines, although more so in the alternate media.

This recent exposé ironically coincided with World Press Freedom Day on May 3. Malaysia is ranked a pathetic 142 out of 196 this year, trailing behind East Timor, Philippines, Indonesia and Cambodia. Journalist CC Liew in The Malaysian Insider lamented that: "Our Sword of Damocles is the Printing Presses and Publications Act." But I don't think this draconian and oppressive law to muzzle dissenting voices will be relaxed anytime soon.

Yet, despite all these, I believe that most Malaysians are still trying to make sense of our hardboiled reality, and scrunching our eyes to catch the elusive silver lining among the very dark clouds overhead. Those who have unfortunately lost all hope however, had also probably left our shores in the droves-some 300,000-odd, over the past 18 months or so!

Deepening crisis of public trust

In the early 2000s, British citizens were sucked into a vortex of public recriminations where doctors faced their greatest nemeses and fallout-e.g. rogue doctors who had became killers, reckless surgeons who had over-stepped their surgical skills, excised body parts that had been withheld by pathologists without permission, etc.

Scandals like these had thereby shaken the very foundations of their much-touted National Health Service. Public trust fell to its lowest ebb. But this was not confined to physicians alone, as the BBC's Reith lectures in 2002, described.

"...We are in the grip of a deepening crisis of public trust... Mistrust and suspicion have spread across all areas of life... Citizens, it is said, no longer trust governments, or politicians, or ministers, or the police, or the courts, or the prison service... Patients, it is said, no longer trust doctors (think of Dr Shipman!)... 'Loss of trust' is in short, a cliché of our times."


So there is nothing exceptional about periodic scandals and crises of public trust around the world. This has always been, since time immemorial. Loutish man had always to be constrained by a Leviathan: by social and/or public laws and regulations to dampen his/her penchant for digressions along easier paths of self-serving mischief!

For Malaysia therefore, this may be just one of these cycles of recrimination or a return to our innate brutish behaviour run amuck! Unfortunately for us, this has run into one protracted debilitating atmosphere, which seemed to have paralysed our nation, our progress, our development.

Decades of mismanagement and personal/political aggrandisement had left us with a mindset that is flawed. We are gripped in a pervasive if simplistic claw-hold that handouts are OK, that 'lebih kurang' mediocrity is good enough. We have become soft and lackadaisical. We are not known for our competitiveness. Our hitherto Asian Tiger star rating is fading.

Down the ladder
Yet when our universities continue to decline down the ladder of competitiveness, we strike out vehemently to say that there are too many flaws in the methodology and that we will not be participating in future surveys. Perhaps the truth hurts, particularly when systematic and entrenched "osteoporosis" had weakened our foundations too much.

A general air of despondency has pervaded our shores. Many of our most important assets, our better-educated and knowledgeable citizens are losing faith and hope. Many choose to be abroad for better opportunities, better working environments, more challenging research climates, and less stifling intellectual environments.

For many it is not simply an economic concern, but the deep-seated anguish of uncertain unattainable personal or family goals, self-actualisation and satisfaction, at home.

For many too, our individual pride and patriotism in our nation, has been repeatedly baited and battered until they have become hollow hurtful clanging jingoisms of desperation-deeply etched as negative memes into our troubled minds!

These are the disturbing developments vis-à-vis the Malaysian sociopolitical scene. Although we are not alone, we are a growing body of cynics. We are increasingly mistrustful toward one another. We seem to be trapped within an ethno-cultural anomie and listlessness, going neither here nor there.

Every day we read and are exposed to relentless streams of callous and salacious actions by politicians, officials, police, judiciary and even among our fellow citizens-corrupt practices, petty thefts, snatch-thefts, daylight robberies, mindless attacks, killings even; child rapes, abandoned babies; police atrocities and excesses, etc.- an endless crescendo of dispiriting stories... It is difficult to remain optimistic or positive.

Our lifestyle standards, purchasing power, shrinking exchange rate, workplace discord and unspoken separateness, uncertain employment and promotional prospects, are causes for concern for the ordinary folk.

Our glut of mass-produced under-qualified university and college graduates ensures that they continue to languish as unemployable. Not that anyone really cares. More money is doled out to retrain them some more! Is this money well-spent? Or is this haemorrhaging into more wastage, into rent-seeking schemes, which produce little to show for?

More and more higher educational facilities are approved without the need to see if these are really required for society's needs, or whether they are sufficiently equipped with amenities and quality teaching staff. Our government-sponsored diploma mills brazenly bid for public offering at the stock exchange, as if such largesse were guaranteed gold seams of profit!

Even our broadband standards have fallen by the wayside and are left far behind our faster growing neighbouring states, despite our earlier initiation into our own Silicon Valley, i.e. our MSC (Multimedia Super Corridor) and Cyberjaya.

After the political tsunami

But political shenanigans and vagaries have clearly shaped and defined public confidence in Malaysian society, ever since March 8, 2008, our so-called political tsunami. Initially, some glimmer of hope for urgent change for the better was ignited. Since then however, political wranglings and political one-upmanship have ratcheted up more than a few notches. Politicians from all fronts have relentlessly pushed and pursued these farces of absurdities to their limits!

While not unique to Malaysia per sé, these "growing pains" are especially true of societies, which are undergoing painful transitions into more credible versions of a mature democracy-where individual human rights and justice concerns take their rightful place as the pinnacle of modern evolved society.

In Malaysia's case however, we appear to have been stuck in a lingering adolescent phase of petulant and stuttering "childhood". The pulls and tugs of small-minded chauvinism and ethnocentric bigotry remain too entrenched, too hardwired to prevent that so important breakaway step into final maturity.

muhyiddin yassin pc 170310Even our DPM, Muhyiddin Yassin (right), could not take that plunge to commit himself as a Malaysian first, for fear of diluting his political capital as an ethnic champion! Our "maverick" former prime minister, Tun Dr Mahathir too, could not escape the grips of this confused identity crisis.

We have yet to fully embrace acceptance and tolerance of our multiethnic, multi-religious diversity, so much touted in our jingoistic shibboleths such as "Malaysia Truly Asia", "1Malaysia", even!

My belief is that this is that juncture where Malaysia is today, at the cusp of possible change, for better or for worse... Dare we hope for the better?

We must move away from intimidating fear and self-censorship. Because this timid mindset only allows cobwebs of prejudice and racism to amass under the proverbial carpet of overarching top-down paternalism of government knows best. Those days are passé; they are over and should be deeply buried!

Increasingly, we must opt for more forthright candidness that might serve us better if only we could harness these differences into a synergistic strength of diversity and a collective unity of purpose. Malaysians have to learn to balance the rule of law with the sagacity to oppose unjust laws and systems when they violate human dignity.

We cannot allow ourselves to be sidetracked by ethnocentric and prejudicial fears and flames of passion, which are fanned by Machiavellian politicians of a bygone era, trying to recapture that lost amber of obsolete ethnic pride and bigotry, of shameless political expediency!

We must consciously strive to finally exorcise the stubborn stains of irrational tribalism and prejudice, the acknowledged corruption of our Malaysian soul so entrenched in ethnically-dominated interests, venal pursuits, rent-seeking political patronage.

This blemish has led to so much economic wastage, opportunity costs and productivity leakages, that even latterly, our Prime Minister was forced into openly acknowledging when announcing the New Economic Model (NEM) for Malaysia.

It is certainly time to rid our Malaysian political scene from rent seeking and corrupt patronage expectations. Merit-based, efficient, competitive and productive enterprises must drive our future transformation. Perhaps at last, we can move forwards, away from what has held us back and debilitated our former strengths and unique position as a rising Asian Tiger economy.

Malaysia must strive to remain relevant and competitive within the greater Asian 21st century and sphere of preeminence. As Malaysians, we must all rise up to the challenge by becoming more truly involved to help reshape the politics of the impossible-namely the art of improving ourselves and our world.

To quote Vaclav Havel again:

"The important thing is that the winners will be the best of us, in the moral, civic, political, and professional sense, regardless of their political affiliations. The future policies and prestige of our state will depend on the personalities we select and later elect to serve as our representative bodies..."

----------------------------------------------
This is a shorter version of my cited lecture to the Malaysian Orthopaedic Association Annual Lecture, in Johor Bahru, 21 May 2010, entitled: "Doctors, Society and Politics"

Monday, July 27, 2009

Yasmin Ahmad, A Truer Malaysian Patriot...

Saturday 25 July 2009, 11.25pm. Yasmin Ahmad has died. Massive stroke. Brain haemorrhage. Abrupt. Mal apropos. Lethal.

Like many Malaysians, I am shocked and I mourn the untimely loss of filmmaker and creative director, Yasmin Ahmad.

Simply put, I mindfully ask why we are yet again losing so many great people, so young, so needlessly, so unforeseen—illustrious souls claimed too prematurely by the grim reaper, the proverbial 'thief in the night'.


I have never met Yasmin Ahmad. Yet, I feel a kindred spirit with this fellow Johorean, perhaps the quintessential Malaysian filmmaker within my generation.


Like many wishful and wistful Malaysians nowadays, we all continue to yearn for a lost time and era, where our ethnic diversity was our amalgamated strength and our unique sense of pride.


Yasmin, I believe, is a truer Malaysian than most of us dare to profess. She was more daring than most, to flesh out a more creative version of what it means to be a citizen of this blessed land, which we call Malaysia.


She dared to explore the darker expressions of racial bigotry within our society, which of late has been sundering our communities, in staggered if with unchecked certainty. Interracial relations have always been touchy nearly taboo subjects, which many Malaysians are at pains to sweep under the carpet of self-censored political correctness.


Publicly, we are at pains to project in most instances a tightly controlled sensitivity, and tongue-biting reservedness, which borders on impenetrable aloofness, but loudly declared if perfunctory camaraderie. However, over time, these less than robust facades get sandpapered away to expose the superficiality and the unburnished colder emotions—of barely submerged antagonism and crude stereotypic dehumanising racial slurs.


During political rhetoric and partisan outbursts, the uglier face of racism surfaces, latterly more often than not. Unleashed anger, hurt-pride, mob-instinct, explode more readily with utterances of irrational bigotry—which create vortices of vicious cycles of indignant recriminations, of plangent hurtful sectarian bombast...


Yet, in subtle contradistinction to these stereotypes, in many Petronas-funded commercials, Yasmin was able to inject a heady stream of poignancy and comic relief which showcase our unique connectedness, our inexplicable destiny, rather than spotlight our skin-deep dissimilarities. In other short films, she was able to finesse uncommonly discussed issues, considered by many to be too raw or too crude to be aired—“The Funeral” was one case in point.

Yet she was able to evoke bittersweet emotions which knew no racial or religious bounds, but which continues to showcase our human foibles and our oft-forgotten sensibilities, in a comically tender fashion, which warms the heart.


She married a Chinese (Tan Yew Leong), to wit, as if to announce to the world that she believed her destiny was meant to be—a Malaysian who was bold enough to live and practice without the oppressive constricts of social religious mores, racial taboos or unspoken frowns of politically-incorrect dissuasions...

Better than that she dared project those hypersensitive touchstones which help us all to question our irrational if misguided
'monkeys off our backs' which tether our better gentler spirit to our uglier crasser emotionalism. For many of us, this emotional stunting remains that deeply entrenched molten lava of illogical ethnocentric superciliousness, our ingrained if misguided belief in our own ethnic supremacy. "Aren't all of us racist in our own hearts?"

Yet, many of us are schizophrenic when it comes to being labelled Malaysians. While we may all look quite different, Malays, Chinese, Indians, Dusun-Kadazans, Ibans, etc., we have whenever we are in any international forum or discourse, declared our proud Malaysian origins. We sense ourselves as different, yet similar and unique in an inexplicable way, in spoken Manglish, "-lah"-accentuated speech patterns, so ingrained in our acculturated mindset that only a Malaysian can understand.


Like so well illustrated by another iconic Malaysian artist, Lat, our Malaysianness must stand us apart, if only because only we can fully appreciate the colourful nuances, the comical stereotypes which enhances rather than demeans our differences. Our uncouthness, our jagged crudities, our slapstick teeth-sucking, nose-sniffing mannerisms, our oddly juxtaposed spoken words are but cultural pearls which only our Malaysianness can decipher and find chuckling meaning and furtive humour...


Indeed, while we had been colonized serially for centuries, Malaysia had been blessed by her fecund land: first from our sequential abundance of natural resources—from tin and rubber, then palm oil, then crude oil and latterly expanding into small medium industries, led particularly by our insightful foray into the then explosive electronics industry.


But perhaps most importantly of all, I strongly believe that Malaysia benefited singularly from her peoples: our unique blend of multi-ethnicity, so jingoistically announced to the world as "Malaysia, truly Asia."
It was this sensitive portrayal of the eclectic Malaysian and his/her interracial tensions that marked the genius in Yasmin Ahmad.

She had variously been branded an ethnic traitor and frequently labelled as controversial, when all she ever did was to dare to expose the fallacies and the down-to-earth idiocies of racial/religious stereotyping and bigotry.


It appears that the Malay heartland was less impressed with Yasmin's talent and derring-do than other non-Malays, who have always embraced her more readily, sensing her passionate understanding and connectedness. Perhaps not wearing her religion on her sleeves, and having married a non-Malay spouse, might have helped shaped her sense of greater ethnic openness and tolerance.

But there was more than met the creative eye of Yasmin Ahmad. I believe Yasmin was a truer patriot, more in deeds and soul-searching honesty than most. She had that extra touch of creativity and sensitivity which transcended ethnic considerations and concentrated on what truly matters, the human spirit and experience, that singular penetrating understanding of interpersonal relationships, in the unique inescapable setting of multiracial Malaysia...

“Sepet” was perhaps Yasmin's best-known work, which won her acclaim and controversial notoriety. A thinly disguised critique of interracial love and emotional relationships heavily tinged with exploits of ethnic bigotry, touched many tender raw spots which were previously considered taboo in Malaysia.

"Sepet" released in 2004, won Malaysian Film Festival Best Film Award (2005), including too several international awards, viz. the Asian Film Award at the Tokyo International Film Festival 2005, the Grand Prix Award at the 2005 Creteil International Women’s Film Festival.

Since her first movie, “Rabun” in 2003, other films followed: “Sepet” (2004), “Gubra” (2006), “Mukhsin” (2006), “Muallaf” (2008) and Talentime (2009).


Such were her magic touches that almost every film made by Yasmin had won some prize or other in the international film scene, marking her as an extraordinary filmmaker whose eye for social analyses had come of age, in an era where serious quality was often trumped for trendiness and kitsch.


In fact her style and talent so captivated Singapore's Prime Minister, that he'd invited Yasmin Ahmad to direct a film for launch at the Youth Olympics in 2010 in Singapore. Alas, this project is now in limbo...

We'd probably lost forever, the opportunity to see yet another work of a genius, of a truly international class film master...


Sleep well, Yasmin. Your films, your influence, your touch, your Malaysianness will yet outlive your short sojourn on earth. May your unswerving efforts and boldness to deconstruct ethnic taboos, religious boundaries and racial bigotry help realise a better, more united Malaysia.


Rest in Peace.


Al-Fatihah.

Friday, August 8, 2008

Shame! Another salacious saga we can do without…

“If thou speakest not I will fill my heart with thy silence and endure it. I will keep still and wait like the night with starry vigil and its head bent low with patience.
“The morning will surely come, the darkness will vanish, and thy voice pour down in golden streams breaking through the sky.
“Then thy words will take wing in songs from every one of my birds' nests, and thy melodies will break forth in flowers in all my forest groves.”
~ Rabindranath Tagore, Gitanjali

Once again the tawdry, the salacious and the senseless seemed to have besmirched our mainstream politics.

Malaysians have been and will be dragged through the mud of explicit sex education of the foulest, most humiliating theatrics, all in the name of rule by law, purportedly to honour the humble request of a lowly citizen who cried foul because he claimed to have been buggered by non other than a potential Prime Minister in waiting!

He must have justice and and his pound of flesh, and our usually lethargic institutions have been marshalled with supreme efficiency and speed, to charge the accused...

At this juncture, I confess to be being biased. Having followed the highs and lows of Anwar Ibrahim's career, his rhetoric and his writings, I have come to the conclusion that he comes across as someone whom I can relate to. This is not to say that I necessarily agree with him in toto, but his ideals, when he passionately articulates or writes on these, are in the right direction.

More than a decade ago when I chanced upon his book on "The Asian Renaissance" I then realised that perhaps finally we have in Malaysia a leader of intellectual quality and substance. Here is evidence of his attempt at urbane conversation as to his ideals and hopes, about what Asians (including Muslims and Malaysians) can do to excel and to engage with the changing modern world. I believe this underlies his enlightened sincerity and moral courage. It certainly is totally incongruous with the accusations that he is a sexual deviant and pervert. Like what any computer would say: it just “does not compute…”

It is true that he is not without flaws, but then again which politician is 'squeakily clean'? For that matter, who amongst men are infallible? Who amongst us are qualified to cast the first stone? Nevertheless, a fair number of people I've spoken to, are still somewhat wary of his seemingly changeable (some have even labelled him chameleon-like) stance on some contentious communal, educational, economic issues.

He has in a limited way acknowledged that he has had a pretty checkered and questionable past during his tenure within the National Front government. Then, some of his ministerial decisions seemed to have been less than convincing, occasionally erratic and some would even say scheming and yes even politically expedient.

But like most people who are learning, adapting and now willing to listen to constantly shifting groundswells of opinions and ideologies, he has personally disavowed some of his poorer judgements of the past. More importantly, he and his colleagues have shown that they have the citizen's welfare and wellbeing at heart, and that policies and ideas are modifiable to cater to the greater good and the better of intentions. (See his recent interview with Shawn Crispin of Asia Times in Malaysia Today.)

Can his avowed pledge to stamp out corruption and nepotism and to promote greater accountability be any less rousing and consonant with our own aspirations? Should one simply be skeptical just because these are too populist? After all, shouldn’t the public expect their mundane concerns to be the motivating foci of their elected representatives?

Perhaps modern politics require one to be adaptable and enduring—most importantly, a successful politician and leader must have an inexhaustible store of strong core values which must continue to underlie his/her basic philosophy for life and an unshakable belief in the general public good...

Notwithstanding all these, the past few years since his freedom from incarceration, have seen the emergence of another Anwar, one who has sufficient conviction and charisma to now cobble together a functional coalition, the Pakatan Rakyat.

For the first time in Malaysian history, we appear to have a truly workable indeed viable alternative, in what is now touted as the preferred modern political reality, i.e. a less fractious but more efficient 2-party system. A closely-balanced 2-party system would allow easier changes of government, because they serve as mutual counterweights, for gritty checks and balances, to forestall vested excesses, corruption and misrule.

These demarcated polities allow for citizens to decide periodically (every 4-5 years) which side they prefer, and also allow them to keep or to spurn when these elected representatives fail to live up to their promises and expectations. No longer can elected parliamentarians be allowed to keep their sinecures, when they are corrupt, ineffective or plainly inept.

For many Malaysians, this represents a new hope, a new spirit of renewal which seemed to have fizzled or disappeared from the vocabulary of the incumbent powers, under the fossilized mindset of the ruling party—50 years tend to entrench one into immovable fortresses of decay and decadence...

Alas, hopeful concepts translating into hard-nosed realities would not easy. Indeed, such a revolutionary change is always thought to be difficult if not impossible to achieve, what with the incumbent powers wielding all the aces in the pack of cards...

Our institutions have been battered and are perhaps at their lowest ebb in morale and certainly in respectability and trustworthiness—public perception of them are at their rock-bottom lows.

Yet, prolonged incumbency and ingrained power-beliefs tend to make our officers of these institutions, imperious and self-protective, dishing out their oft repeated echoes that might is right, and that as the authorities still in charge, they would broach no dissent to their dictates and pronouncements, as if these were cast in concrete!

Some have lamented that following the shock upset of the March 8, 2008 elections, the government has been locked down in denial mode, and are no longer listening—somehow our rakyat's voices seem to no longer carry the weight of sense and balance anymore. Not only are their protestations and queries falling on deaf ears, they are given a talking down to, instead!

Some have detected great consternation and disbelief among the unaccustomed politicians under siege. Many are still disbelieving that they are now in such a shaky position of power dilution. They are so angry and indignant, that they are now bent on punishing those whom they believed have wrought such an unprepared cataclysm upon them!

The Lingam video debacle chronicling unabashed tempering of the judiciary must take the cake for executive abuse and excesses. It reaffirmed the rakyat's distaste of a tainted legal system, and solidified its worst suspicion that some very senior judges who were then in cahoots with some lawyers, can be bought hook, line and sinker!

Worse, the then Attorney-General (AG, our legal system's highest office) and the Inspector General of Police (IGP, highest ranking police officer) have now been accused of misconduct, tempering of evidence and witnesses, allegedly during their then lesser roles and ranks in the 1998 public-relations disaster!

Thus, it is not surprising that for the hard-pressed police force and the AG’s office, they would be more inclined to easily believe a young strapping accuser, rather than to perhaps consider that the accuser might have been lying, and that other motives may be involved. What better way to resolve once and for all, such a festering boil of unprecedented proportions in the shape and form of Anwar Ibrahim?

Once again, the possibility of righting that expunged evidence and parading of the sex-stained and DNA-tainted mattress, that undignified black-eye incident they had suffered some ten years ago, might seem appealing…

But then they fail to understand that the rakyat are no longer pliant believers in whatever spins the authorities are dishing out. They want to know why and more. And that if that were to be the case, they are questioning why the police is not entertaining other possible scenarios other than the ‘scripted.’

Why indeed is it so much more believable that the accused is capable of such a crime, compared with other more heinous crimes for which statutory declarations have also been made against other VIPs? Why indeed, the differential treatment and fast-tracked energies to charge with such haste?

The rakyat wants to know who the accuser is acting for, and for what personal gains to expose one's most intimate soul, nay, even body part and name, to such a glare of cheap and shameless publicity?

But, I suppose it is possible that if one is truly sexually assaulted, then one's demand for justice can be very strong, to redress such a wrong of shameful 'assault' against one's nature... Although most if not all rape victims tend to be so traumatized and self-ashamed, they would avoid undue publicity at all costs…

Indeed, for many among the Malaysian public, we wonder who would benefit from this highly damaging and publicly humiliating "character assassination to silence an effective leader of the political opposition" (to quote former US vice-president Al Gore)?

It is patently obvious to all political pundits and even the most neutral observer, that perhaps such a high profile politician as Anwar Ibrahim has been too charismatic, too popular, and who is by all intents and purposes too ready and poised at the cusp of re-entering his much derailed political destiny...

Apparently, this momentum—this tryst with destiny must be stopped at all cost, some believe... The timeliness of it all must be serendipity at its chanciest best, any other lottery would have been more difficult to imagine.

Notwithstanding the inept denials by the highest echelons of our society, the undisguised attempt to charge the opposition designate leader with the religiously-tainted odium of sodomy, cannot be but starkly clear to all except those ostriches whose heads are buried in the sand of self-blinkered ignoramuses.

What was surprising is the fact that the final charge seemed to have been whittled down to one of consensual if illegal form of sex, i.e. sodomy, without the hint of assault (i.e. rape) and only on one occasion, at one locale. This is in spite of the earlier leaked reports and accusations that the "poor" victim pleading for justice had been "sexually assaulted" at least several times!

One wonders if this was the best that the police and prosecutors could come up with, because of the inadvertently-leaked medical report from Pusrawi Hospital which had found no such injury, and which would have made the later reports untenable, especially if totally discordant but exaggerated reports were to emerge just a few hours or days after the first examination!

Again, maybe because justice sometimes works in mysterious ways, another statutory declaration (SD) has emerged—this time by the same beleaguered Dr Mohamed Osman, on the harrowing and intimidating experience of trying to be true to his calling and profession. As a medical professional myself, I salute his valiant courage in steadfastly standing up to this impudent affront of such despicable pressure, if this were to be true.

Yet again, sadly, he has chosen to expose the machinations of certain powers through the only sane and foolhardy brave soul of RPK (Raja Petra Kamaruddin). Has this audacious web portal of Malaysia Today now become the bastion sanctuary for all whistle-blowers, because no other institution can now be trusted?

Not surprisingly though, the police is now investigating this SD with the view that it contains too many 'inaccuracies' and that it served to paint the police in a rather poor light... Once again, the police are upset. This SD’s authenticity is now in doubt, there are inconsistencies you see, so investigations are underway… Police CID chief has argued that this release of the SD is an attempt to undermine the police and discredit their work… "We strongly believe that this article is intended solely to skew public perception and to undermine police authority," Bakri said.

Alas, such is now what most Malaysians already know and believe. This SD is simply but one of a long litany of sequences of events which already has long undermined the credibility of the authorities even before this.

The police and the other institutions must now show us that they can rise above their waning rhetoric, indignant statements, selective prosecution, and show the public that they can be truly professional and impartial.

Would this be possible under such a climate of doubt and recriminations?

Or would salacity trump sagacity once again to the detriment of Malaysia…

Alas, who should the poor Malaysian public now believe?

An abbreviated article has been published in malaysiakini as Another salacious saga we can do without

Saturday, July 26, 2008

Obama's Audacity of Improbable Hope

4 years ago, when Barack Obama was given the podium to address the Democrat convention, it raised many an eyebrow. Mainly because, as an African American, he had been given such an accolade, and at such a tender age at that.

At that time I remembered downloading his speech, and comparing it with others including Al Sharpton, John Kerry, John Edwards and Al Gore. Even then, he had shown remarkable talent in rhetoric in an evangelical, inspiring, rabble-rousing, exhortation sort of way...

Since then, I must confess that I have become one of the religiously-converted hordes of Obama-manic fans.

His historical perspective as one who was born into a mixed-race marriage, forms the basis of his contention that for the American dream, his was one of unimaginable "improbable hope." And he has been declaiming this point relentlessly to inspire legions of people who hanker for change, betterment and hope. "This is our moment," exhorts Obama.

I watched him during his recent Berlin address (25 July, 2008). Undoubtedly, although he admitted wryly that he did not look like any of his predecessors before him (he being the first African American or man of colour), he stood shoulder to shoulder with the best and the exceptionally brilliant--200,000 Berliners were on hand to experience his charismatic aura, and to cheer him on.

Obama is certainly captivating and personable. He is without doubt a great orator who effuses with goose-pimpling inspiring rhetoric, but at the same time enunciating many bold expansive ideas which I hope he will be able to implement once he becomes the President.

It is true that many of his rally-calls border on generalities rather than specifics, as some have criticised, but in this world of nebulous moral confusion, 'them-and-us' American exceptionalism and tired battle-weary politics, it is refreshing to have someone like him to continue to offer us hope!

Most importantly, he comes across as a supremely confident statesman, one who is not shy of confronting controversies head-on, one who dares to admit his nation's faults--warts and all, while acknowledging that he still loved America very much, that he can still hope to evoke and provoke change, a rallying-cry to remake the world even...

One of my pet issues on nuclear disarmament received a rare attention boost in his Berlin speech, and gives global citizens the hope that one day our children and our chidren's children can live free from the spectre of nuclear arms and war, forever:




"This is the moment when we must renew the goal of a world without nuclear weapons. The two superpowers that faced each other across the wall of this city came too close too often to destroying all we have built and all that we love. With that wall gone, we need not stand idly by and watch the further spread of the deadly atom. It is time to secure all loose nuclear materials; to stop the spread of nuclear weapons; and to reduce the arsenals from another era. This is the moment to begin the work of seeking the peace of a world without nuclear weapons."

In many ways, the American story is one which is singular and unmatchable in history, even as it continues to metamorphose today. Barack Obama must represent the newest incarnation of an evolving mindset of progressive enlightened Americans.

The many contradictions: the self-serving politics, the gross excesses of mass consumerism, pop culture, the entrepreneurial energies and innovative productivity are quintessential of the American experience. Yet despite it all, it has always put on the forefront, the inalienable and ineradicable right of the individual.

Most importantly, there is always that indisputable possibility for political change that is inbuilt into its rigidly upheld Constitution. Every American demands and acknowledges this right, and would fiercely fight to keep this flame alight.

It is true that the USA is also replete with its occasional gridlock politics of the executive, i.e. the President, the Senate and the Congress, but these partisan vested interests are tempered and safeguarded by a truly independent Judiciary (the Supreme Court). America allows an unprecedented capacity to question itself, to reinvent itself.

It is true that often enough, America tends to overreach itself and its influence, much to the dismay and anger of the watching world. Yet, its near sole superpower status means that it must continue to engage itself in the affairs of other nations.

Sometimes, America's interference is rejected outright especially when these strike too close to the loutish antics and extremes of some autocratic and despotic regimes.

At other times, the world angrily demands that a cautious and isolationist America engages more rapidly and responsibly to prevent further genocidal collapse and catastrophic abuse of humanity, especially of the marginalised and dispossessed minorities such as in Bosnia, Darfur, Liberia, etc.

Some are very grudgingly accepted, but most times American brazenness is rejected because of jingoistic claims of national sovereignty and independence. Sadly, Malaysia has even now sounded such 'nationalistic' clarion calls to stop the US of A from interfering with our laws, our interpretation of it or worse, how we choose to enact these for overtly political purposes... See Malaysiakini's Gov't demands US stop 'interfering'

As the world's sole-surviving (but certainly not flawless) Leviathan, it has an unenviable task to make some sense of this truly multifarious world of precariously perched balance of good and evil: to curb mankind's dalliance with widely disparate and fissiparous destinies, and to temper and deter our insuppressibly innate tribalism and brutishness...

Notwithstanding this, I remain hopeful that our political leadership can rise above itself amidst such a quagmire of floundering and directionless political uncertainty.

At this current juncture of political stalemate, can any Malaysian truly feel optimistic that good and truth will prevail over so much mucky political dissimulations, prevarications, propaganda and outright lies?

Will heart-warming unalloyed ideas and durable ideals once again emerge to uplift the Malaysian spirit to wonder again with hope, and to rekindle that daring to dream for change for the better?

Will we ever be so lucky to see another Malaysian leader of calibre to lead us out of this horrendous mess, with even half the vision and charisma of Obama?

Will this be 'our moment', soon?

I can dream, can't I?

Vero Possumus! (“Yes, we can!”)


“I know my country has not perfected itself. We’ve made our share of mistakes, and there are times when our actions around the world have not lived up to our best intentions."
“People of Berlin, and people of the world, the scale of our challenge is great. The road ahead will be long. But I come before you to say that we are heirs to a struggle for freedom. We are a people of improbable hope. With an eye toward the future, with resolve in our hearts, let us remember this history, and answer our destiny, and remake the world once again.”


A shorter version is published in malaysiakini